Cut the crap
If citizens of modern countries can keep their countries clean, why can’t we?
MANALI ROHINESH
Pics of gods are a deterrent to people urinating on walls. Pic courtesy
Indians are travelling a lot these days, which is a good thing because travelling widens your horizons considerably. What I really enjoy hearing about is how amazed they all seem at the level of cleanliness and civic manners found there.
It’s such a pity that we need to go abroad to learn it ourselves. I have some questions to ask such globetrotters.
* Do you not know that defecating, urinating, spitting and worse in public is not exactly entertainment for others? These things are not done only by the lower class and illiterate people in India. A lot of educated people get out of cars and water the plants, where they can find them!
* Do you know that your pampered pets called Frisky, Rhino, Cocoa etc are not allowed to poop in public? Since they don’t know that, you should be vigilant and pick up after them, the way you would be expected to do if you were walking your pet in New York, Sydney, London or Moscow. I’ve seen so many well-heeled pet owners – yes, the ones who look like they travel quite a bit – who look the other way while their pets are decorating places like Worli Seaface and Marine Drive. No wonder, pets are going to be banned from Marine Drive.
* You can bet some bleeding heart will object to this and it most likely will be a pet owner, who never picks up his/her doggy poo. Why should they? Aren’t they paying a poor BMC worker to do that?
Would they be using this line of argument with a US cop who would have fined them with a look of disgust on his face. The minute he said something like ‘Go back to India and do this because it’s not allowed here’, they would have gone crying to the media and claimed racial abuse. I, for one, would applaud the cop’s attitude. After all, he’s doing his job and maintaining law and order in his country, so obviously he’s not going to accept tourists and immigrants treating his country like a public toilet.
Foreign countries are clean and great places to visit because they are kept that way by their citizens. I don’t think they have started importing our poor BMC souls yet to clean up after them. We need to wake up and take responsibility for our (and our pets’) actions and not expect a ‘clean and green’ country to emerge like a miracle overnight. We need to make it happen.
The only constant thing is change and a drastic change in attitude would help. To start with, importing a desire to keep our country clean would be a great idea. Let’s live and learn the good stuff.
I’ve never been to India, but I live in the States, and I’ve traveled a lot in Europe and Japan. I find it really interesting that you’re holding modern countries up as a standard to aspire to, because I think most western cities are actually pretty disgusting. I was just in Philadelphia last weekend, where many streets are full of trash and the risk of stepping in dog poop is pretty high. In Paris, the dog poop situation is even worse, and there are whole sections of the city that reek of piss because drunk men apparently prefer to pee outside on a stone wall instead of in a public toilet just a few meters away.
I think your basic premise is right, that we should all aspire to keeping our cities clean and safe… but I don’t want you to be misled into thinking that western cities are somehow clean enough that you can eat off the sidewalk, or that the clean downtown areas in cities are nice because the citizens actually care and make an effort to keep them that way– if there weren’t cleaning crews, they’d probably be full of litter just like the less-central, less touristy areas.
To be fair, though, I admit I’ve never seen anyone defecate in the street in a western city. That would be… surprising.